Why a Private Fishing Charter in Kona is Worth It vs. Group Tours

March 11, 2025
A group of people standing next to each other holding fish

When planning a fishing trip in Kona, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is whether to book a private fishing charter or join a group (shared) charter. While both options get you out on the water, they offer vastly different experiences. If you want personalized service, more fishing time, and a trip tailored to your needs, a private charter is the way to go. Let’s break down the differences so you can make the best choice for your adventure!

Feature Private Charter Shared Charter
Boat Exclusivity Your group only Multiple groups/strangers
Personalized Attention Dedicated captain & crew Shared attention with other guests
Fishing Strategy Tailored to your preferences (within reason) Generalized for all passengers
Space & Comfort Plenty of room to move around Limited space, can be crowded
Catch Ownership Skillet follows responsible fishing practices; see policy below Fish may be shared or given to crew
Trip Customization Flexible options, but safety and conditions dictate final plans Set schedule & one-size-fits-all experience
Ideal For Families, serious anglers, special occasions Budget-conscious solo travelers or small groups

While group charters are budget-friendly, they come with trade-offs—less space, less control over the trip, and an unpredictable social environment. Private charters provide a superior experience with more fishing time, personal attention, and complete trip customization within safe and responsible limits.

Why Private Charters Offer a Better Experience

1. More Space & Comfort

Let’s face it—fishing in a crowded space isn’t fun. On a shared boat, you’re shoulder-to-shoulder with strangers, competing for prime spots.

  • With a private charter, the boat is yours—plenty of space to relax, move around, and fully enjoy the experience.


2. Personalized Service from the Captain & Crew

On a private trip, the captain and crew focus 100% on you. Whether you’re a first-timer needing guidance or an experienced angler looking for specific species, the trip is tailored to your group (within safe and practical limits).

  • Expert guidance on technique, fish species, and best fishing spots.
  • One-on-one coaching for beginners.


3. No Unwanted Distractions or Group Dynamics

With a shared charter, you never know who you’ll be fishing with.

You could end up with loud, inexperienced, or even intoxicated passengers.

Fishing preferences may clash—some people want trophy fish, others just want a scenic cruise.

The captain must split attention among all guests, leaving less time for your questions or needs.

  • With a private charter, you set the vibe—whether it’s a laid-back family trip or a serious angling adventure.


4. A Safe & Professional Experience

While private charters offer flexibility, the captain has the ultimate responsibility for safety and well-being on board. This includes the authority to stop or adjust the trip for reasons such as:

Inclement weather or unsafe sea conditions.

  • Passenger behavior that disrupts safety or enjoyment.
  • Ensuring the best possible experience within safe limits.
  • Your captain’s experience ensures that your trip is both enjoyable and responsible, with decisions made based on real-time conditions.


5. Skillet Sportfishing’s Responsible Fishing Policy

  • Skillet Sportfishing follows responsible fishing practices and adheres to local regulations.
  • Upon request, we will clean and cut up a designated portion of the catch per charter, providing enough fish for each guest to enjoy a few meals while on the island.
  • Ahi (Yellowfin Tuna) exceeding 100 pounds remains with the boat. 
  • Blue Marlin over 100 pounds is strictly catch and release.



This ensures sustainable fishing while still allowing guests to enjoy the rewards of their trip.


Who Should Book a Private Charter?

  • Serious Anglers – Want to maximize your chances of landing trophy fish? A private charter lets you focus on the best fishing techniques with expert guidance.
  • Families & First-Timers – Avoid the chaos of group tours and get one-on-one attention to make your trip stress-free and fun.
  • Special Occasions – Whether it’s a birthday, honeymoon, or corporate outing, a private trip offers an unforgettable experience.
A man and a woman are fishing on a boat

“The Skillet is very clean and well maintained. There was enough room onboard for our group of 6 to be comfortable.” - Verified Fishing Booker Review

A man is holding a large fish on a boat

Why Private Charters Are Worth It?

A private fishing charter in Kona is the ultimate experience—more space, personal attention, full customization (within reason), and a higher-quality fishing trip overall. While shared charters may save you a few bucks, they come with too many trade-offs.

🎣 Ready TO GO FISHING? 🎣

If you want the best fishing experience in Kona, book your private fishing adventure with Skillet Sportfishing today!!

BOOK YOUR FISHING CHARTER
May 21, 2025
New to fishing in Kona? Watch our quick video guide to meet the captain, check out the boat, and learn what kind of adventure to expect on the water with Skillet Sportfishing.
A boat fishing boat on the water with the Big Island of Hawaii in the background
May 8, 2025
Discover why deep sea fishing in Kona, Hawaii is on every angler’s bucket list. From grander marlin to year-round action just minutes from shore, see what makes Kona a world-class fishing destination—and how to book your own private charter.
More Posts